Unacceptable

(F grade)

Marginal

(C- to C+)

Proficient

(B- to B+)

Exemplary

(A- to A+)

The total number of suggestions is insufficient.

The total number of suggested strategies is much less than expected, given the topic and the number of bulletin board replies.

The total number of suggested strategies is adequate given the topic and the number of bulletin board replies.

The total number of strategies is impressive given the topic and the number of bulletin board replies.

A large percentage of the suggested strategies are insufficient in their ability to convey information to the reader.  The reader would be unable to implement those strategies.

A small percentage of the suggested strategies are insufficient in their ability to convey information to the reader.  The reader would be unable to implement those strategies.

All suggested strategies are comprehendible to the reader, and could probably be implemented based on the rather general description provided.

All suggested strategies are detailed and highly descriptive.  The reader would have no difficulty comprehending and implementing the suggestions.

The writing style and mechanics are not yet acceptable for graduate work.

Writing style and mechanics are adequate but need improvement.

Writing style and mechanics are generally correct.

Writing style and mechanics are at a high level.