Author: Tom McIntyre    DoctorMac@BehaviorAdvisor.com

ADD
(Attention Deficit Disorder)
and
ADHD
(Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder)

What Are They All About?




***Caution*** This page attempts to simplify a very complex condition.  While providing an overview, it lacks detail and depth.  The reader is advised to investigate the topic in a more precise and in-depth manner.
 

Does the youngster's attention span remind you of when you push the scan button on your car radio?   Is s/he Einstein from the neck up, but Fred Astaire from the neck down?  That youngster might have an attention and/or overactivity disorder.

    School is oftentimes the first place where characteristics of ADD are noted or viewed as problematic.  It may be that the school setting is the first place where the youngster is asked to stay seated for long periods of time, maintain extended attention to a live individual, persist on a task, or wait one's turn.  "Curious" kids who seem to attend to everything, often become known as "distractible" when they are unable to filter out extraneous sights and noises in the classroom.  Youngsters with ADD experience difficulties in the areas necessary for academic success: starting work assignments, completing tasks, interacting cooperatively with others, following directions, making smooth transitions, and managing multi-step tasks.  Excessive activity levels, talkativeness, interrupting, fidgeting, active and out of seat behavior, and underdeveloped social skills may also be evident.  A number of factors effect performance including time of day, amount of rest or fatigue, adequacy of supervision, adequacy of medication, and so forth.

    Since Dr. George Still first described "moral turpitude" (lack of moral self control) in 1902, the fields of education and mental health have strived to devise more appropriate names, better categorization systems, more accurate assessment procedures, and more effective teaching strategies.  It is one of the areas of greatest contention in the field of special needs.  Should these youngsters be labeled as "special ed"?  How many kids have these conditions?  Do these conditions really exist or are they simply excuses for poor parenting?  It all depends on who you listen to.  Below is a synopsis of the literature.
 

Diagnosis
    There is no definitive test for for ADD/ADHD.  Diagnosis is made by a physician after referral by parents and/or educators.  It usually takes 2-3 office visits before the diagnosis is final.  The physician should consider the impressions of the parents and teachers (perhaps written on a survey form).  Diagnosis should be made based on the criteria established in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of the American Psychiatric Association (DSM-5, 2014)   As with the earlier version of the DSM, in the DSM-5 manual, the overall condition is known as "Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder" (ADD and ADHD are not separated...even though most educational professionals tend to separate ADD and ADHD).  Under this condition are three different types of ADHD: (1) "ADHD combined type" (the most common type) in which there is found in the youngster six or more symptoms of inattention (from a list of nine symptoms) and six or more symptoms of hyperactivity/impulsivity (from a list of nine symptoms).  The symptoms must be observed in two or more settings (i.e., home and one class at school, two different classes at school); (2) "ADHD, Predominantly inattentive type" in which six or more symptoms of inattention are observed, but fewer than six symptoms of hyperactivity-impulsivity are seen; and (3) "ADHD, Predominantly hyperactive-impulsive type" with fewer than six signs of inattention, but six or more signs of hyperactivity-impulsivity.  Be aware that most professionals also recognize a fourth category "ADHD with aggression"

One caution: Many physicians use their own criteria, failing to fully consider the DSM-5 criteria.  Be certain to ask your family physician if the diagnosis was based on the DSM-5 guidelines.  Diagnostic procedures that involve brain scans are being tested and studied at present
 

Click here to view the DSM-5 criteria for labeling a youngster as ADD/ADHD

 

 

Random Thought: Perhaps the ADD part of ADHD isn't really an attentional problem at all. These kids are able to attend to a lot more things than me during a short period of time. Maybe it's best thought of as more of a "filtering" problem... being able to block out stimuli that is unimportant to the task being addressed in the moment.

I was trying to daydream, but my mind kept wandering.

 

(Depression in Children") can present itself in distractible or active behavior.  Depression should be ruled out previous to a diagnosis of ADD or ADHD.
 

How Many Kids Have These Conditions?
 When it comes to ADD and ADHD, the professional literature contains estimates of 1 to 20% of school aged youth.  The National Institute of Health estimates 5 to 10%.  The use of  DSM-V criteria would result in about a 3 to 5% prevalence of the conditions.  The conditions are more frequently found in boys (3 or 4 times more often).

    ADD/ADHD is the most common childhood neurobehavioral disorder and it is estimated that ½ to 2/3 of individuals will carry the condition into adolescence and adulthood, often being viewed by others as "talkative", "scatterbrained", and/or "forgetful".  They are also at greater risk for experiencing social ills (i.e., family problems, job difficulties).
 

What Causes ADD/ADHD?
 That answer depends on who you ask.  Just about any cause you can think of has it's adherents.  The following are some of the common views on what causes or contributes to the conditions.

-prenatal problems
-prenatal exposure to cigarettes

-prenatal exposure to alcohol

-premature birth
-brain development/minimal brain dysfunction
-inner ear problems
-chemical imbalance
-thyroid problems
-sex linked chromosome
-inherited behavioral traits
-pollution
-fluorescent lights
-fast paced media and video games
-vitamin deficiencies
-lack of calcium
-food allergies
-yeast
-food additives
-low blood sugar
-heart problems
-inconsistent or lax discipline at home
-boring lessons
-poor behavior management skills of the teacher
-misdiagnosis of anxiety or depression

    In "true" ADD and ADHD, biochemical reactions related to the brain's neurotransmitters, especially the dopamine and serotonin pathways are involved.  Frontal lobes (the brain's center for attention and impulsivity) of ADHD individuals have been found to use less glucose (resulting in less energy) and demonstrate less electrical activity.
 

Treatments for ADD/ADHD
   If s/he is diagnosed with this condition, should your child be placed on powerful ADHD medications right away? While you will find advocates for all sorts of interventions (e.g., megavitamin therapy, chiropractic treatment, play therapy, biofeedback, sensory integration training, diet changes), most are questionable at best.  Nearly all positions can supply personal testimonials on effectiveness.  However, only psychostimulant medications (and it's combination with behavior management strategies) have any scientific proof supporting their effectiveness.  There has been a dramatic increase in the use of these "psychotropic" medications.  Most teachers have heard about Ritalin, a medication used in the USA at a rate at least 5 times higher than the rest of the world.  Although "vitamin R" is the most common medication for these conditions, many others exist (e.g., Adderal, Cylert, Premoline, Dexadrine, and various anti-depressants like Tofranil, Norpramin, and Elavil).  The aforementioned medications will not be effective for one out of five ADD/ADHD pupils.
  For pre-adolescents, medications like Ritalin, despite being stimulants, work well (reports vary with 65-90% positive treatment ratings).  Known as the "reciprocal effect", it is not known exactly why a stimulant calms these youngsters and helps them to concentrate.  Some believe that hyperactive and distractible behavior is an attempt to stimulate an underperforming brain.  The stimulant is believed to "speed up" the brain, increasing the level of dopamine in the frontal lobe of the brain which regulates attention and impulsivity, so that it needs less stimulation.  In other words, the drugs calm the individual by making the brain work more efficiently.  Research indicates that medication does work better than behavior modification therapy, and a combination of the two interventions is NOT more effective than the medication alone (NY Times, page A8, 12/15/99).  However, among the 70% of these youngsters who also had depression or anxiety with their condition, the combination did yield significant benefits beyond medication alone.  Educational remediation and special education often accompany the medication, as do parent training, family counseling, youth counseling, or other intervention.

     Ritalin may be available in a time release form, or the youngster may need to receive the medication every three to four hours.  It takes about 30 minutes to take effect.  Cylert takes days to weeks to become effective, but thereafter is needed only once per day.  A new drug, Concerta (a new form of the drug Methlyphenidate, commonly known as Ritalin) is now available.  Unlike Ritalin, which requires two or three doses per day, Concerta lasts 12 hours, making in-school and after-school dosing unnecessary.  Concerta comes in tablet form and is taken in the morning before school.  Strattera, a non-stimulant medication from Lilly Pharmaceuticals was introduced around 2003.

Side effects often accompany the medications.  The most common are loss of appetite, weight loss, irritability when the medication wears off, stomach pains, dry mouth, and problems falling asleep.  Less common side effects are slowed growth, tic disorders, and problems with flexible thinking.  As a teacher who sees the youngster often, you should document any possible side effects and report them to the parents/physician.

Medication is not a substitute for therapy and training.  It helps kids to better respond to the help.  It is estimated that about 90% of youngsters with ADHD benefit from the administration of medication.
 

Should They, or Can They Be Labeled "Special Ed"? (United States Education Law)
     While the conditions are not listed as one of the special education categories, the youngsters often receive special education services by being labeled "learning disabled" (if ADD is the primary concern), "emotionally disturbed" (if ADHD is the main concern), or "Other health impaired" (if parents or school personnel dislike the other two labels).  Many ADD individuals will also have accompanying conditions such as a learning disability, emotional or behavior disorder, Tourette's Syndrome, etc. that must be considered in their educational planning.

     If symptoms do not meet the criteria of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (the special education law), or school personnel hinder IDEA identification, parents sometimes seek to have their child labeled under the less stringent conditions of Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (as amended).  Under section 504, a civil rights act, disabled youngsters are guaranteed school services to meet their needs.  A person with a disability is defined as "any person who has a physical or mental impairment which substantially limits a major life activity."  Certainly schooling and socializing are major life activities.

    If the student qualifies for special services under Section 504, the school must make determine and meet the educational needs of that youngster.

There is no one test for identifying whether youngsters have ADD or ADHD.  While physicians are often involved in the identification procedure, the U.S. Office of Education does NOT require a medical evaluation.  However, some states have added the additional requirement of a physician's evaluation.

    The Professional Group for Attention and Related Disorders (PGARD) recommends a two-tier process of evaluation for identifying ADD and ADHD.  The first tier contains a clinical evaluation to determine whether the youngster's symptoms match the criteria listed in DSM-5.  The second level is comprised of an educational evaluation to determine if the condition is having a substantial negative impact on academic and classroom performance.  All individuals familiar with this youngster should contribute to the process which attempts to identify when the behaviors began, how often and under what circumstances they appear, and the effect on the youngster's academics, psychological state, and social life.  It is hoped that this multi-source process will provide an accurate overall picture of the boy/girl, and help in identification and programming.
 

TIME OUT FOR A LITTLE HUMOR: Click here for cartoons about ADD & ADHD
#1    Might there be a genetic component in ADD?
#2     Teachers and ADD

 
 
Click here for an impulsivity joke
 
  
   

Fetch Dr. Mac's Home Page    Did you hear what I said?