Background :
I run the school’s high school newspaper, The 411. It is
a wonderful opportunity for the students, who have language-based learning
difficulties, to work on skills that they find very difficult. It
also is an activity that many students partake in to include on their college
resumes. Currently I have a student staff of 19 writers. We
meet twice a week to discuss, work on, edit, and layout the current articles
for a bi-monthly issue. The attendance to the newspaper meetings
and the writing of the articles has become very sparse. The students
I am working with possess many executive function disorders, and can be
very forgetful.
I have tried several approaches to motivate the students to take
more of a vested interest in what they are doing. The first thing
I tried was a pizza party. Attendance was quite high during this
meeting, but when the next meeting came around and there was work to be
done, conveniently the students forgot about it. The next thing I
tried was acting like a tough guy, but of course this wasn’t received well
by the students because the ones that were at the meeting were not in need
of any type of scolding or talking too.
Goal :
In order to make the students understand that if they were going
to have articles published in the paper that they would need to both attend
the meetings and do some work, I decided to check around on the www.behavioradvisor.com
website. I found a whole page describing The Contract idea and decided
that this method was very good for motivating this particular group of
students to rise to the challenges of being part of the school newspaper.
Implementation :
In March I had an announcement over the loud speaker that called
a mandatory meeting of the paper for its regularly scheduled time on Monday
afternoons. I subsequently went and personally spoke to each child
to make sure that he/she was aware of this meeting and would be in attendance.
When the meeting time arrived all but two students showed up. I had
the other students paged to the room and they appeared, apologizing for
having forgotten about the meeting.
I began the meeting by talking about how being on the newspaper
was an honor and also a large responsibility on their parts. I praised
their prior successes, and asked them what they thought they could do to
improve the current attendance and article turn-in rate. They came
up with all the right ideas about making sure they come to meetings and
about following deadlines by themselves. I asked the group, “So how
do we make sure that you follow the rules and ideas that you just named?”
The students didn’t seem to know. I suggested, “Could we have some
kind of contract that we work up in order to make sure that you doing your
articles and coming to the meetings on time?” They all seemed to
think that this was a great idea. So together on the dry erase board,
which I later typed up and distributed to all the children (and mailed
home to their parents) we devised a contract.
The contract had the requirements of being part of the paper
that the students had to sign and date, and it also had a penalty and a
reward clause. The penalty clause was that non-compliance with the
rules that they drafted about attendance and dead-lines would lead to their
name not being included in the paper (which was important to the many students
who wanted to list this as a major academic form of an extra-curricular
activity for college applications) and that they would no longer be able
to hold an editorial position in the paper. The reward clause was
that they would be eligible for a school journalism award solely by meeting
attendance and deadline requirements. The reward was picked by the
students as their stipulation to following the rules that they devised.
I also added that we would have a pizza party at the end of every issue,
and only those with near perfect attendance would be allowed to attend.
I printed up this contract, signed it with the student, and we
each kept one copy. In addition to the student’s copy, one copy was
sent home so that the parents could see what the importance was of finishing
an article or attending a meeting. (The parents are usually more
eager than the student to have these Newspaper credentials appear on their
child’s application to schools.)
Outcome :
The behavior change that occurred after these contracts were
drafted was remarkable. Attendance was nearly perfect from the time
the third issue went into planning, until the very end when the printing
and folding took place. The students seemed to feel a true sense
of responsibility and ownership over what they were doing, it’s importance,
and what hung in the balance for them. The parents were very
pleased with the idea, the students themselves were excited to be fulfilling
what they saw as an obligation, and I as the advisor was quite excited
and pleased as well. I rewarded the students with praise, and of
course, a pizza party.
Analysis :
I feel that the contracts were such a success because it simply
provided motivation for things that the students already had wanted to
accomplish. They wanted to get their name on the paper under the
heading of their own article. They wanted to get to put down that
they worked on the school newspaper on their college forms. They
also wanted the satisfaction of completing an article and having met a
goal that they had set for themselves.
The contract behavior change was wonderful for the 19 students
who are a part of the newspaper group. I will soon try to adapt the
contract idea and implement it in a class that I teach where the homework
ethic has begun to decline. The results have truly increased my faith
in my students’ abilities, and I believe it has given them more faith and
more belief in their own selves. In my opinion, that alone is a solid
success.